Thursday, November 19, 2026

Energy, security tango to chaotic world orchestra

Crescent Dunes Solar Energy Project, Tonopah, Nevada, 2025
RJ Peltz-Steele CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
Energy and global security are inextricably linked, and that's concerning in a politically volatile world of vanishing fossil fuels, proliferating nuclear technology, and faltering commitment to solar and wind.

In the Global Law Classroom, a multi-national program in legal education that I incorporate into my comparative law class, one excellent unit of study focuses on global energy and security law. American contributions to the unit come from my colleagues Professor Chad Austin, formerly Navy JAG, and Major Andrew Irvine, both faculty at the U.S. Air Force Academy.

Their content each year gets me thinking about how interrelated energy and security are, an increasing cause for concern amid global warnings of waning natural resources. (See my visit to Kuwait in April 2025.) This year the energy-and-security study arrived upon what seemed to me a confluence of current events in various veins of energy alternatives.

In October 2025, the Trump Administration "quietly canceled the nation's largest solar project," CNN reported. Esmeralda 7 was a series of seven solar projects on 118,000 acres of federal desert in Nevada that could have generated 6.2 gigawatts (GW) at peak output, the equivalent of power for 2 million homes.

I visited the Crescent Dunes Solar Energy Project in Tonopah, Nevada, in 2025. It's brilliant, literally and figuratively, and an otherworldly sight. Yet its capacity is only 110 MW at peak output, less than 2% the design capacity of Esmeralda 7.

The Bureau of Land Management never gave a reason for the cancellation, The New York Times reported. But the move fits within the broader federal policy of blocking solar and wind projects while promoting oil and gas extraction.

Parts for offshore windmills prepare for deployment
at the port of Le Havre, France, 2026.

RJ Peltz-Steele CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

Accordingly, the Administration also canceled some $4 billion in offshore wind investments, TechCrunch calculated. In a rare turnabout, a lawsuit by state attorneys general, including mine in Rhode Island, prevailed in the First Circuit in June in their effort to push through federal permitting for projects already under way. At stake in the lawsuit are billions of dollars in investment, some of it sunken, thousands of green jobs, and a wind-power equivalent of service to more than 4 million homes, according to New York Governor Kathy Hochul.

Though anti-solar and anti-wind, American policy is not purely pro-carbon. The Administration is looking to grow the nuclear sector. A 2025 executive order aimed to speed federal approval both for new, advanced reactors, and for the restart of defunct stations. A fact sheet from the Department of Energy in July outlined progress. Just last week, advanced-reactor projects in Texas got the green light.

The United States is hardly alone in the world, striking out in the nuclear vein, and it seems the earth will be speckled with nuclear reactors, big and small, in short order. The B1M, a short-documentary producer on construction and one of my favorite YouTube channels, published in October an item about a $25 billion "nuclear megaproject" that Russia is building on Turkey's Mediterranean coast. 

The first reactor at Turkey's Akuuyu Nuclear site is set to start this year, and the projected capacity of the facility is 4.2 GW. That amounts to 10% of Turkish energy demand, according to The B1M, and is about 1.5 times the capacity of the delayed and over-budget Hinkley Point C station, "Britain's $57BN Nuclear Nightmare," which comprises just two of eight reactors the UK wants to build on the isles by 2050.

The Akuuyu builder meanwhile has an identical project under way in Egypt. And Turkey is shopping for another such facility to be built on its Black Sea coast.

There's a lot to worry about here in terms of global security. The Akuuyu project is a first of its kind financing model in that Russia will retain both ownership and control of the facility. That means 10% of the energy supply of a NATO country will be fully under Russian control. 

The arrangement reminded me of quid pro quo Chinese and Russian investment in the developing world, such as in ports in Africa and South Asia. Will countries there be Russia's next hosts? Central Asia can hardly say no. And Akuuyu comes at a time when the United States is slashing foreign ties and aid.

The United States is, however, working to bring nuclear technology to Saudi Arabia, where a Houthi drone strike recently disabled a major oil pipeline. A nuclear-studded earth thus raises another frightening prospect.

I visited Chernobyl in 2013, before
the New Shelter Arch was completed.

RJ Peltz-Steele CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
The B1M recently published short films on the aftermath of the Chernobyl and Fukushima nuclear disasters. Neither site is a rosy picture today. And remember, these were "disasters" where things turned out relatively well. Neither rendered the better part of a continent uninhabitable, as very well might have happened. Neither emitted steam clouds that swept deadly radiation around the planet.

The largest moveable structure ever built, indeed a credit to human ingenuity, "the New Shelter Arch" placed over the Chernobyl site in 2016 was damaged in a Russian drone strike in February 2025. That's especially problematic because the radiation shield depended in part on pressurized containment that is now irreparably compromised.

Meanwhile, engineers at Fukushima, where containment is practically impossible because of the soft earth and seaside location, are unsure whether they'll be able to meet a 2050 cleanup goal. They are struggling to develop and build robots that can enter conditions that would kill a human in seconds and extract super-hot radioactive material that remains buried under debris and sea water. Experts rather suspect that it might take 200 years to neutralize the site, if it can be done at all. 

Incidentally, I learned last week from a campus webinar with Chancellor Mark Fuller of UMass Dartmouth, the main campus to which is attached UMass Law, where I work, about the expansion of a geothermal system to additional campus buildings with the aid of a $1.1 million state grant. This green alternative appears to have U.S. Department of Energy support. I knew little about geothermal. From what I have read in just the last few days, the trick is front-end investment to build a quality system. The "loop field" must run deep in the earth and is vulnerable to corrosion. But if done right, geothermal can pay off. Systems run 24/7, have a small footprint on land, and generate negligible emissions.

According to the Millennium Alliance for Humanity and the Biosphere (MAHB) at Stanford University, oil and natural gas supplies will last the world only another 50 to 60 years at current consumption rates. Coal will run out in 110 to 150 years.

That means my daughter, now in her 20s, probably will live to see a world that no longer relies on oil and gas, one way or another. That's a frightening prospect when the United States is doubling down on oil and gas dependence and throwing up roadblocks to wind and solar. That civilian nuclear technology is proliferating worldwide and becoming a currency of warring powers is cold comfort.

At the same time, we are growing ever more reliant on artificial intelligence, ill reputed for its electricity and cooling needs that figured so prominently as a U.S. midterm-election issue. Maybe AI will solve the problem of its own energy supply before the climate clock runs down.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Mounting e-bike, e-scooter risk, exacerbated by police impotence, proves bike path compromise a failure

East Bay Bike Path in Barrington, R.I., autumn 2026
RJ Peltz-Steele CC-BY-NC-SA 4.0
With chaotically changing laws, passive police, rampant violators, and rising risk, Rhode Island's experiment with electric vehicles on the East Bay Bike Path has proved a failure.

I wrote in September 2025 about the change in Rhode Island law that allowed class 1 e-bikes on the East Bay Bike Path. I then lauded legislators, including my colleague in political science at Roger Williams University and state Rep. June Speakman for brokering the compromise that permitted on the bike path a "[b]icycle equipped with an electric motor that provides assistance only when the rider is pedaling, and that ceases to provide assistance when the electric bicycle reaches twenty miles per hour (20 mph)."

But I wrote too that the proof would be in the pudding of enforcement. A year later, the pudding is spoiled. Enforcement is near naught, and running and bicycling on the bike path has become a risky exercise in dodging electric vehicles of all sizes—up to and including electric off-highway vehicles (OHVs), full-on-electric motorbikes, running 35 mph and faster.

A class 2 e-bike, the Pedego Trail Tracker
is not allowed on the R.I. East Bay Bike Path.

EBikePro, 2015, via Wikimedia Commons CC BY-SA 4.0
To be clear, electric OHVs were never allowed on the bike path. The 2025 law disallowed class-2 and class-3 e-bikes; an OHV is neither of those. Nevertheless, the permissive policy on class-1 e-bikes created an ambiguity that exposed police non-enforcement. Users of all kinds of disallowed vehicles have been happy to exploit the breach. 

A few weeks ago, I had a near miss by a teen on such a vehicle. I complained to my local police in Barrington, R.I. Police responded that if I see a vehicle operating unlawfully on the bike path, I should call the police non-emergency number. 

Well, first, I don't carry my cell phone when I run, and I don't want to. Second, an electric motorbike I spy in the town center will be out of town in just over three minutes anyway. I understood the police instruction to mean that there will be no enforcement, and I have seen none.

Collaterally, the town has seen an explosion in the use of e-scooters by minors. In June, a 15-year-old boy riding on an e-scooter the wrong way in the parking lot of the main shopping center in town struck a minivan. The boy, who fortunately was wearing a helmet, was injured. After that event, the shopping center banned e-scooters anywhere on the property. Then in October, the town passed an ordinance banning e-scooters from town sidewalks, parks, and public parking lots. 

E-scooters are still permitted on the bike path, even though they are powered wholly electrically. State law prohibits minors below driving age from riding e-bikes entirely, reasoning that they are capable of higher speeds, akin to motor vehicles. Of course, with no enforcement on the bike path, anything goes there.

According to news reports, town police are enforcing the rules on roads, in the shopping center, and on town property. Barrington Police Chief Michael Correia met with chagrined middle schoolers last week to explain the web of rules and tell them that their safety is the main concern of police (East Bay RI). "Kids have been killed in southeast Massachusetts," Correia told the kids.

ER doctors in Massachusetts raised the alarm in August about "a dramatic spike in children hurt in e-bike and electric scooter crashes," WBUR News (Boston) reported (registration required). "Doctors say the injuries are often far more severe than pedal bike crashes.

"'We've seen so many catastrophic TBIs—traumatic brain injuries—in children who are riding or being hit by these things, or being hit by a car because they're riding in high-speed traffic and they don't know the rules of the road,' said Dr. Cornelia Griggs, a pediatric surgeon at Mass General Brigham for Children."

Captured weekly in the local paper, flaring tensions have triggered ugly interactions between pedestrians and electric vehicle users, sometimes, respectively, between adults and kids. A psychiatrist and mother of two middle schoolers who organized the police chief's visit with students, Monissa Solberg, wrote in a letter to The Barrington Times that her kids are afraid to go out on their e-scooters because they "feel like public enemy number one in their hometown."

On the R.I. East Bay Bike Path, a minor
on an e-scooter is engrossed in her
smartphone, November 2026.

RJ Peltz-Steele CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
A frequent user of the East Bay Bike Path, I'm not so vexed by kids on e-scooters. I have seen some moving fast, with and without helmets, and with their eyes fixed on smartphones. That's not unworrisome. But most kids I see are attentive, polite, and not moving that fast. I don't want to toss the barrel for a few bad apples.

Allies of the Solberg position, however, in their plaintive letters to the editor, have tried my patience. Too often they fail to recognize the real risks of e-bikes, and the real problem of non-enforcement. Moreover, they whine, what are children to do without their electric vehicles? How ever will they get to school, or to be with friends? Pity the children!

Cry this curmudgeon a river. I'm pretty sure the kids still have two feet. Each. And there are no limits on bicycles. You remember those. Bikes. On the bike path. The entire length of the bike path within Barrington is less than four miles. Where are these kids having to commute?

WBUR's On Point did a show in September asking "How should e-bikes be regulated?" The host observed that she is not bothered even by racing cyclists, because the action of powering a bike on one's own seems to focus the attention. I feel that way, too, both as a bicyclist and a pedestrian. The racers move fast, but they tend to be the most responsible navigators out there.

Now electric motorbikes, running 30, 35, or more miles per hour, zip within inches of my arms and legs when I am on foot on the bike path. Their riders wear helmets. I don't. They hold smartphones in their hands while they ride. I'm no longer of an age that I might recover easily from a collision. One momentarily inattentive rider could mean I never run again.

I don't want to toss the barrel for a few bad apples. But sometimes, as the old saying actually says, "One bad apple spoils the barrel."

The legislature's experiment allowing class 1 electric vehicles on the bike path was laudable and worth a try. But always it depended on enforcement. There is none. Now we see that the experiment has failed.

It's time to return the bike path to its intended users, people under their own power.

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Should lots, not elections, choose political leaders?

RJ Peltz-Steele with Google Gemini CC0 1.0
In a recent episode of Freakonomics Radio, "Does Democracy Really Need Elections?," journalist Stephen J. Dubner explored sortition, the selection of public officials by lot.

Dubner came to the inquiry by way of his service on a criminal jury in a drug case. He was inspired by the seriousness with which jurors undertook their responsibility and rendered a verdict for the prosecution. Dubner had the defense lawyer from the case on the show to understand how lawyers understand the jury process.

But the notion of a jury chosen more or less randomly led Dubner down a rabbit hole, into the world of sortition, also called "civic lottery," which dates to Ancient Greece. Dubner explored sortition with the help of experts, including "recovering politician" Terry Bouricius, author of the Routledge open access book, Democracy Without Politicians: Government by the People (2026), and political science Professor Hélène Landemore, author of Politics Without Politicians: The Case for Citizen Rule (Penguin Random House 2026).

I thought of sortition as an interesting but fringe idea. I was wrong. Landemore explained how sortition was a dominant mode of democracy from Ancient Greece until the Enlightenment in the 18th century. According to Bouricius, "Aristotle said, lotteries are democratic, and elections are oligarchic." While some powers of government in Ancient Greece were reserved for an elite, much of governance was charged to a randomly selected citizen council.

A problem with elections, if it's not obvious, is that they favor candidates with certain personality traits, such as confidence, which might not be justified, and even a willingness to lie. The recognition accords with the idea, as old as Plato, that persons who desire power ought not be given it. Properly informed, shy and modest people are no less capable of making wise policy decisions, but they tend to get no say in modern democracy.

Of course, elections also distort democracy with money, which affords a candidate access to the electorate. The role of money might actually explain why sortition went out of favor at the very time that the United States was constituted.

According to the experts, the U.S. framers specifically wanted not to empower the masses. And it wasn't just the threat to norms of power that enslaved persons and women might mount. The framers regarded wealth and social status as indicative of the wisdom required to govern—Aristotle's oligarchy.

In other words, according to sortition advocates, the anti-democratic distortion of American politics by wealth is not a dysfunction, but a design feature. Sortition is a fix.

Dubner's exploration examined experiments with sortition as it's popped up here and there in the world, in places such as British Columbia, Iceland, Ireland, and, curiously, as reported recently by Planet Money, Connecticut. 

A problem with sortition, Dubner worked out, is getting politicians who benefit from the status quo to buy in. That might be possible, Bouricius posited, if you start on an issue-by-issue basis. There are questions that are too hot-potato for politicians, who might be eager to hand them off. Climate change might be one, he said.

Monday, November 16, 2026

Ala. defamation verdict evidences changing times

RJ Peltz-Steele with Google Gemini CC0 1.0
In late August, an Alabama jury entered a $9.25 million defamation verdict against The New York Times, signaling that impunity long enjoyed by the institutional press can no longer be taken for granted.

The case arose from a Times story that erroneously placed plaintiff Kai Spears, a University of Alabama freshman basketball player, at the scene of a fatal shooting on campus.

Commentary on the case is abundant, and I don't aim to restate it better. I recommend coverage by George MJ Perry at "Abuse of Process," Eugene Volokh at Reason, Bill Grueskin at the Columbia Journalism Review, and Katie Robertson at the Times itself. 

Multiple media outlets reported that the defamation loss was the Times's first in 50 years. The verdict included $7.5 million in punitive damages, which the court reduced to comport with a punitive-to-compensatory statutory ratio cap of three to one. At the time of this writing and since September 28, defense motions are pending to toss the jury verdict (JNOV) and for reduction of damages (remittitur).

What's remarkable about the case is not the verdict, but that Spears reached the jury at all. As I wrote most recently here in October 2025 and in 2 Tortz (2025 ed.) ("Reconsidering Sullivan"), and verbalized in Dan Greenberg's American Libel (2025), the "actual malice" doctrine that originated with New York Times Co. v. Sullivan (U.S. 1964) perversely, if well meaningly, incentivizes sloppy journalism and presents genuinely injured plaintiffs with insurmountable obstacles to tort compensation.

Key rulings in the instant case surprisingly went against the Times and likewise against extant if modestly waning media defense bulwarks some 60 years old. First, the plaintiff was ruled a private, not public, figure. Only public figures trigger the federal constitutional doctrine of Sullivan. 

A first big problem with Sullivan has been that the public-private distinction has eroded in the information age, in which anyone can be a "celebrity" of a sort, in some niche market. Spears might not have been a public figure as a freshman walk-on circa 1970, but every member on the Alabama squad has a public persona online today. The ruling thus pushes back in an effort to redraw a public-private balance fit for the internet era.

Second, even though Sullivan did not, therefore, require proof of "actual malice"—defendant's intentional falsity, actual knowledge of falsity, or reckless disregard of falsity—the plaintiff still convinced the jury of actual malice for the purpose of winning punitive damages.

A second big problem with Sullivan has been the refusal of courts to find actual malice with less than smoking-gun evidence of known falsehood, moving the actual malice rule problematically close to the old and justifiably abandoned common law concept of evil motive. The jury here heard evidence of Times arrogance and sloppiness in getting the facts rights when a young man's integrity and well-being were in jeopardy. Allowing such examination of the editorial process pushes back against a long-standing judicial norm of heedless deference to purported journalistic method.

There is a gratifying irony in that the Spears case arose in Alabama, the same state that generated Sullivan. Appeal seems inevitable. But times have changed, and I like the plaintiff's odds in today's Eleventh Circuit and U.S. Supreme Court. 

I remain committed to journalism as an enterprise and to its importance in the democratic project. But the imbalance in tort law wrought by Sullivan and progeny in fact contributed to the decay of modern journalism. Unaccountability facilitated the dissolution of professionalism, and unredressed reputational harm fostered resentment and distrust.

A turning of the tide to let tort law do its work would be in the interests of the public and journalism alike.

The case is Spears v. N.Y. Times Co., No. 7:23-cv-00692 (N.D. Ala. Aug. 31, 2026), before Judge Annemarie Carney Axon in Birmingham.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Norwegian footballer claims publicity right in ponytail

Image from Norwegian Air Shuttle ad
Presumed ©; demonstrative fair use
As my Manchester City Football Club teeters in the face of punitive relegation as threatened consequence of financial improprieties, I was pleased during this international break to be distracted by an amusing Erling Haaland story in intellectual property law.

As both an MCFC supporter and Norway aficionado, the latter owing to long-time family friends there, I recently devoured Haaland: The Biography by Norwegian football writer and broadcaster Lars Sivertsen. Erling Braut Haaland is a Bryne-reared, 6'5", now-26-year-old striker who took Premier League football by storm, shattering records and quickly establishing himself as one of the top players in the world. 

The best thing about Haaland for my money is that he also seems like a super decent guy, just a boy from Bryne. He's the sort of superstar who remembers the little people, such as Torbjørg Haugen, the woman who cooked for his youth team and always made sure he ate.

Both athletes, Haaland's parents inspired a relentless work ethic and sporting values such as loyalty and teamsmanship. His mother, Gry Marita Braut, was a champion heptathlete for Norway in the 1990s, and his father is Alf-Inge "Alfie" Haaland, a footballer who played his best years at City, before injury ended his career. 

For five years of footballing, Haaland sported a blonde ponytail. As Inc. put it, the immediately recognizable styling became a "business asset." In 2024, Haaland bought a stake in a hair-tie company and became a brand ambassador for a shampoo, Inc. explained. It was headline news when Haaland turned up for the 2026-27 season sporting a new buzz cut. Balding former manager Pep Guardiola (and I) was aghast at the wasted potential. 

Erling Haaland, 2022
Egghead06 via Wikimedia Commons
CC BY-SA 4.0

Meanwhile, Haaland had sported the usual ponytail when he played for the Norwegian national team at the World Cup over the summer. Norwegian Air Shuttle, a low-cost airline based outside of Oslo, ran a World Cup advertising campaign at that time featuring a plane with a blonde ponytail and the slogan, "We've never looked more Norwegian."

Alas, the campaign apparently did not have Haaland's imprimatur. Haaland sued in Oslo District Court, according to AFP via Courthouse News on October 1.

Tom Collins and Kathy Harford at Stevens & Bolton (UK) penned an insightful legal analysis from a multi-jurisdictional perspective of the overlapping intellectual property theories implicated by the reported claim, including right of publicity (not available in UK) and trademark.

From a U.S. perspective, Haaland's claim is strong, even in the absence of a registered trademark, provided there is right-of-publicity protection in the jurisdiction. Faber Law tracks right of publicity in the United States, where just more than half of states have statutes, and maybe a dozen more recognize a common law right.

The Restatement (Third) of Unfair Competition (1995) describes tortious appropriation as when "[o]ne ... appropriates the commercial value of a person’s identity by using without consent the person’s name, likeness, or other indicia of identity for purposes of trade ...."

The Haaland claim seems a slam dunk, insofar as this rule pertains. There is zero question that the Norwegian Air Shuttle ad was aimed at conjuring the likeness of Haaland in the mind of the viewer. Norwegian might claim its purpose to have been World Cup patriotism, in part. But there can be no serious doubt that the company wishes to sell tickets, too, and the ad was designed to further trade. Though Norwegian abandoned trans-Atlantic service amid the pandemic, it operates flights to cities across Europe, including London and Manchester. As a consumer, I'm left with the impression that support for Haaland and support for Norwegian are interchangeable.

I have found no English-language source that has laid eyes on the Haaland complaint, but MiGFlug reported that the case arises under the Norwegian Marketing Control Act, which makes sense. That's the statutory mechanism that creates right-of-publicity liability in civil-law Norway. As explained by Oslo-based Bryn Aarflot, the Marketing Control Act covers "lookalike" claims even in the absence of trademark registration. 

From the Kongesagaer (1899 ed.)
Internet Archive, public domain
The Haaland claim arises when celebrities and high-profile athletes increasingly, and with mixed results, are seeking intellectual property protection for abstractions that conjure identity in the mind of the viewer, without express reference, such as sport celebration moves. Collins and Harford observed that artificial intelligence will make claims over fanciful images more frequent, as AI makes it easier to put a ponytail on an airplane.  

According to the Sweden Herald, Haaland v. Norwegian Air Shuttle is scheduled for trial in Oslo District court on March 16-18, 2027.

Meanwhile, Haaland is making news still for being the boy who made good for hometown Bryne. Erling and father Alfie recently spent 1.3 million Norwegian kroner, about US$136,000, to purchase at auction a rare book of Viking history and donate it to the Bryne local library. According to The Guardian, the book is "the only surviving privately owned edition" of Snorre Sturlasons Kongesagaer (Snorre Sturlason’s Royal Sagas), published in 1594. The Guardian explained:

Snorri’s royal sagas chronicle the history of the Old Norse Viking and medieval kings of Norway, regarded by many Norwegians as a key document of national identity. The stories, about kings, queens, farmers and warriors, were first told orally and then written down by the Icelander Snorri Sturlason in the mid-13th century.

Via video, Haaland told assembled Bryne children that he was interested in Vikings from a young age and reads to his son, who turns two in December.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Posner, 87, was well known to law students

Judge Richard A. Posner
chensiyuan via Wikimedia Commons
CC BY-SA 1.0
Renowned federal judge and legal scholar Richard A. Posner died on November 10.

Adam Liptak wrote a superb obituary for The New York Times. 

The Liptak obituary referenced a famously enjoyable profile of Posner in The New Yorker in 2001, penned by staff writer Larissa MacFarquhar. My favorite line in that piece, quoted by Liptak, is when Posner compared himself to his cat:

"'I have exactly the same personality as my cat,' Posner likes to say. 'I am cold, furtive, callous, snobbish, selfish, and playful, but with a streak of cruelty.'"

In studies such as Fred Shapiro's, Posner is routinely identified as a most-cited legal scholar of all time. Accordingly, he makes an outsized appearance in treatises in law school, so has had immense influence on generations of lawyers and law professors.

In my tort law textbooks for law students, I gently characterized Posner as "cantankerous." 

Students encounter him first in 1 Tortz (2025 ed.), in a study of negligence I derived from the prior work of a mentor, Professor Marshall Shapo. In the study, Judge Learned Hand famously ruled against a tugboat company for failing to have a radio that might have averted an accident, even though radios were not yet standard in the business. 

In counterpoint, in Chaulk v. Volkswagen (7th Cir. 1986), a dissenting Judge Posner railed against "a system of people’s justice, where six laymen are allowed to condemn an entire industry on the basis of absurd testimony by a professional witness." From Posner's perspective, a court that uses tort law to override industry norms, whether through the rationalization of a Hand analysis or the artifact of a lay jury, usurps the authority of a duly elected legislature or regulatory body.

Posner is mentioned more than 50 times in 1 & 2 Tortz (2025 ed.), which excerpt his court opinions and scholarly work.

Judge Posner died in Chicago at age 87.

Thursday, November 12, 2026

Negligence suit beats liability waiver at kids' gym

Stuck in the Middle, 2010
DieselDemon via Flickr CC BY 2.0
A liability waiver at a children's gym cannot block a negligence suit over a five-year-old's broken arm, the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled earlier this week.

The ruling is straightforward and on point. What's surprising is that the high court's reversal was needed in the face a of a state law plainly nullifying gym waivers—and that the law exists, in contravention of American law's usual passion to enforce boilerplate.

Ava was five when she broke her arm falling off a beam at The Little Gym of West Boylston, west of Boston. It was Ava's second year at The Little Gym, part of a global network of recreational facilities "dedicated to helping kids build strength and confidence ... one cartwheel at a time." Ava's father had signed a standard waiver, or release—formally, an express assumption of risk—promising not to sue the gym for negligence if there were an accident, the court opinion recounted.

Alas, Massachusetts has a law that says, "No contract for health club services may contain any provisions whereby the buyer agrees not to assert against the seller ... of the health club services contract any claim or defense arising out of ... the buyer's activities at the health club."

Most of the statute is about consumer protection, limiting the shady contract practices for which gyms were once renowned and still are teased, such as excessively long membership terms and difficult-to-escape automatic renewals. Even the statutory provision here at issue focused on lawsuits about club contracts, before the legislature added the "buyer's activities" phrase in 1985.

The dispute resolved by the high court focused on whether The Little Gym, with its specialized focus on children and services structured in classes, is a "health club" within the meaning of the waiver ban. The statutory definition is broad, comprising businesses offering "instruction, training or assistance in the preservation, maintenance, encouragement or development of physical fitness, conditioning or well being." 

The definition then employs that loathsome legal-ese, "includ[ing], but not limited to," and lists a plethora of examples: "health spas, sports, tennis, racquet ball, platform tennis and health clubs, figure salons, health studios, gymnasiums, weight control centers or studios, martial arts and self-defense schools, or any other similar course of physical training."

"Including, but not limited to" is a safeguard against application of the interpretive canon, expressio unius est exclusio alterius, meaning the specification of some items suggests the intentional exclusion of others. I say "loathsome," because "including" is supposed to indicate non-exhaustiveness by definition. 

But lawyers will lawyer. The Little Gym here tried to differentiate its market niche by pointing to dissimilarities from a conventional adult gym. The court had little difficulty illustrating the controlling commonality of The Little Gym's wellness mission. I was surprised that the lower court had been seduced by the gym's argument.

What surprised me most, though, is the existence of the waiver-nullifying statute. I teach torts in Massachusetts, and, I confess, I did not know about this law.

As it turns out, Massachusetts is not unique, but such laws are rare. A 2019 survey by Dalby Wyant found laws nullifying gym negligence waivers in five other states: Connecticut, Louisiana, Montana, New York, and Virginia. Elsewhere, some states have much more modest limitations, disallowing waiver for gross negligence or recklessness, for example, but allowing waiver for negligence. Poking around online, I found that bills to override gym waivers are popular rallying causes for legislators but rarely pass. Industry advocates such as the Health & Fitness Association research and track such legislation.

The statutory nullification of a waiver, especially one signed by and restricting recovery for an adult, cuts against the American ethos of freedom of contract. Despite consumer frustration with boilerplate, and despite the now-well-known impossibility of reading all of the clickwrap terms and conditions that attach to our every transaction, the overwhelming trend in American law is to favor enforceability. Inroads on the approach are few and far between, and as European-law-driven cookie-notice banners online demonstrate, enhancing the informedness of consumer acquiescence is easier said than done.

Though usually I'm quick to rush to the ramparts for consumers, I find appealing the enforceability of negligence waivers for gyms. The theory of the enforceability of such contracts regardless of subjective consumer understanding, and amid a dearth of market alternatives, is that the freedom to contract allows a business model to thrive without the burden of potential tort liability—if with the tandem drawback that some people will get hurt and have no recourse.

Me at Anytime Fitness, Hong Kong Mong Kok, unsupervised, 2026
RJ Peltz-Steele CC BY-NC-SA 4.0

I'm a member of Anytime Fitness (AF), and I get unabashedly giddy over the 24/7 business model. I can visit AF any time, any day, regardless of whether staff are present. After a long day, or a night class, I don't have to race to the gym before it closes, like I did at the YMCA. Moreover, I use AFs around the country and around the world. A midnight gym visit when my body hasn't adjusted to Hong Kong time can be just the thing.

I've signed a liability waiver at my local AF, in Rhode Island, which presumably controls at all locations—likely including Massachusetts, per choice of law conventions. Yet I've often wondered how AF can exist, legally, and get insurance. I try to imagine how the conversation went down when someone who owned a line of gyms went to general counsel and proposed opening 24/7 with no staff.

If I were counsel, I would have said, You must have lost your mind. Waiver or no waiver, you want to let ordinary, untrained people, the unwashed masses, just walk around with unfettered access to our heavy equipment that is designed specifically to strain their bodies to the breaking point, and with no supervision whatsoever? Ha. Haha. Hahaha. 

Now I find out that AFs operate even in states where those waivers might be nullified by statute. It's enough to make one suspect that what chambers of commerce bemoan as the unbearable weight of an out-of-control tort system is not actually stifling business innovation in America. 

It ought be remembered, surviving a motion to dismiss is still a far cry from winning a negligence suit. At least based on the preliminary factual record as summarized by the court, I'm doubtful that Ava can show negligence by The Little Gym. It seems to me that a kid falling off a beam now and then, even landing the wrong way on an arm, is something that's going to happen at a kids' gym no matter how close the supervision. But we'll see. Ava's attorney lives to rush the ramparts for another day.

The case is Cross v. BeFree Enterprises (Mass. Nov. 10, 2026). Associate Justice Gabrielle R. Wolohojian wrote the unanimous opinion of the court.

See you at the gym. 

Monday, November 9, 2026

Perry pieces blast business model of higher ed

George MJ Perry has lately published two superb commentaries on dysfunction in higher education, both citing Prof. Kenneth Westhues's classic, The Envy of Excellence: Administrative Mobbing of High-Achieving Professors (Mellen Press 2006).

Perry is always worth reading at "Abuse of Process," and he publishes widely besides. I met Perry virtually through the most recent Niagara Conference on Workplace Mobbing (NCWM) in July. I became a fan immediately, and we connected after the conference. 

Perry and I have in common an interest in the intersection of law, journalism, and sport. Perry is a track-and-field athlete, sport performance coach, businessperson, and writer. As well, Perry is a U.S. Navy veteran who specialized in submarine warfare, coincidentally the same as law librarian and veteran Misty Peltz-Steele, my wife and chief strategist.

At the Niagara Conference, Perry led an informative and riveting panel, "From Organizational Mobbing to Public Exile." The panel posited the credible and distressing thesis that contemporary media transform workplace mobbings into public cancellations—see the congruity I described in 2021—thus compounding the trauma inflicted on mobbing victims. The panel discussion touched on the adjacent subjects of media ethics, defamation law, and the right to erasure in data protection.

RJ Peltz-Steele with Google Gemini CC0 1.0
Last week, Perry published "When Universities Pretend to Be Businesses" at The James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal. In the lead, he explained: 

Since at least the early twentieth century, universities have flirted with America's penchant for "running things like a business." But like government, non-profits, and other non-businesses that try to be something they are not, universities' scattershot copycatting of business practices creates new harms to the institutions and the people within them.

More than "flirting," I'd say full-on embracing. 

The thesis resonated with me, especially working at a public university that is not the state system's well endowed "flagship." Faculty achievement at my university often is quantified in dollars, i.e., how much grant money a faculty member brings in. Meanwhile we take precious few measurements of student attainment and do almost nothing to assess how our alumni enrich the world.

Similarly, curricular programs are assessed according to cost-benefit analysis. As a result, market demand in fields such as business and technology drives resource allocation to those departments. The likes of liberal arts are edged out. Poorly remunerative fields such as journalism operate at threadbare minimums.

My university is not unusual in this vein. But that's not how universities are supposed to work. In the classical conception, the university is a bastion of knowledge for its intrinsic worth. It is axiomatic that the preservation and dissemination of knowledge in all fields is essential for the advancement of human civilization. The founding of the University of Bologna in 1088 marked the endpoint of the Dark Ages, a time when Roman knowledge and law were rediscovered.

Today, higher education, especially in the United States and increasingly elsewhere in the world, is dominated by private commercial interests, a worrisomely pervasive demonstration of capitalism run amuck. In such an environment, the historical, civic responsibility of the public university should only be heightened over financial incentives.

Yet funding models for public universities such as mine run flatly contrary to the civic mission. Budgets come vanishingly from public subsidies, and rather from sport-aligned private fundraising (the "flagship" model) or eat-what-you-kill tuition and fees (the rest of us). Unsurprisingly, the result is a higher ed system that reflects ever expanding socioeconomic disparity as nakedly as K12 schools funded by property taxes—the original American sin, one might say.

Perry observed the irony that universities teach business, management, and public administration, yet seem themselves not to understand the important social role dictated by their not-for-profit status. And among the many hazards of running a university like a business is a deterioration of professional relationships built on trust, or what Westhues described as "unwritten rules [and] reciprocal loyalties."

Instead, academic interaction is reduced to the bottom-line letter of the business contract. Characteristically, at my university, where faculty are compulsorily unionized, the collective bargaining agreement (CBA) is the be-all-end-all. If a benefit or privilege is not in the CBA, faculty can forgeddaboudit. If there is a faculty duty in the CBA, then it is meticulously enforced, regardless of whether it serves evolving educational needs.

Perry quoted Westhues at the Niagara conference: "'Academic life has grown emptier, merely contractual. A market mentality has penetrated into more and more aspects of life. When everything has a price, nothing really matters.'"

That very deterioration of professionalism on the university campus leads to the problem Perry wrote about in an earlier piece in late October. For "Reality's Last Stand," he published "The University's War on Excellence." The piece explained why workplace mobbing and social cancellation occur with alarming frequency in the academic environment.

"Elaborate contracts are the prototypical 'inaccessible texts,' of which university bureaucracies are particularly prolific producers," Perry posited. Corollary to arcane contracts and procedures are written and unwritten human-resource assessments of who is and who is not a "team player." Such "[i]naccessible texts are easily weaponized in workplace mobbing," he wrote.

Antithetically, but correspondingly with the civic responsibility of the university, faculty are in a "weird" and very not-corporate employment arrangement. The administration works for the faculty, not the other way around. Tenure is a feature of this arrangement. It was designed to protect faculty from firing or other adverse employment action, both to shield expression of informed opinion on matters of public affairs, and to shield unpopular decisions in academic governance.

This arrangement is all but forgotten in the contemporary university-as-business model. Tenure has withered on the vine, as universities figured out how to circumvent it contractually. Courts shirked any role in social accountability for the university and deferred to reductionist contractualism. Perry aptly quoted Paul Siskind, legislative director at New York Healthy Workplace Advocates:

"Tenure, as a doctrine, says you can only be fired for just cause. In real life, employers can come up with very flimsy reasons and even lies that justify their 'just cause.' There is no accountability outside of the school itself unless you work for a union school, and then you have a grievance process."

But that, too, is a shallow promise.

"Due process doesn't mean that the procedure itself has to be fair and it doesn't mean that the outcome has to be fair. It just means they have a procedure and they followed it." 

Mobbing researchers such as Prof. Peter Wylie (video) have demonstrated that unions, owing to their nature as collective actors, are as likely to be perpetrators of mobbing as defenders of victims.

With professional values undermined and labor guardrails stripped away, faculty are no longer shining guardians of the ivory tower. They are mere cogs in the machine, toiling to satisfy corporatocratic taskmasters. In this environment, excellence and merit give way to group-think and sycophancy. Base instincts run roughshod, and conditions are ripe for social dysfunctions in the workplace, such as mobbing.

At a union meeting last week—I went in my capacity as a representative of the law faculty, though I am not a union member—the brokenness of the system was evident. Rank distrust of the institution and abysmal morale were cautiously buoyed by "blue wave" election results. But, I thought but did not say, I have no confidence that purportedly labor-friendly legislators will care to effect any systemic change. They have in the past rather only shifted benefits to their own favored interest groups.

"Universities are upstream of culture, society, and politics," Perry observed. Ultimately, dysfunction in the university "is a cultural problem within universities, not a legislative or regulatory one."

So fixated are today's universities on the almighty dollar, I am skeptical that the ship can be turned around; that the creation and transmission of knowledge might ever again be the overriding university mission; that, dare I suggest it, we might reimagine universities as institutions that are supposed to lose money. Universities are supposed to be investments in the greater good, generating unquantifiable intangibles in the people who support, protect, and grow our very democracy and the rule of law.

I hope my skepticism is ill founded. It is disappointing to think that in the journey of human enlightenment since 1088, we are not on an ever ascendant curve, but on the downslope of a repeating waveform.

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

Trekkers commit two admirals to eternal rest

Ensign Pavel Chekov manned navigation, foreground, 
in Star Trek: The Original Series. The set lives on at Star 
Trek: The Original Series Set Tour
, where I visited in 2025.

RJ Peltz-Steele CC BY-NC-SA 4.0
Star Trek fans lost two storied admirals last week in Patrick Stewart, "Captain Jean-Luc Picard" of The Next Generation franchise, and Walter Koenig, "Ensign Pavel Chekov" of The Original Series cast.

Stewart and Koenig contributed vitally to making Star Trek the paradigmatically utopian science-fiction exploration of the human condition that it has been for 60 years. Both actors embraced their Trek stardom, rather than, as many actors do, wringing their hands over typecasting in fanciful fiction. 

A classically trained Shakespearean stage actor, Stewart nonetheless reveled in science fiction in film and television, taking on roles such as Charles Xavier in the X-Men universe, and, in his 80s, reprising the role of Captain Picard for three seasons of an eponymous Paramount TV series, 2020-23. 

"For huge numbers of people, I will always be Jean-Luc Picard, and that's fine," Stewart told The Independent in 2003, Ars Technica repeated. "I really believe we created an admirable individual." No pun intended, I'm sure; Star Trek stories saw both the captain and ensign promoted to admiral before all was said and done.

Koenig was a favored guest on the Star Trek convention circuit and joined fan fiction projects, such as New Voyages and Renegades, as a writer and actor. (More on Star Trek fan fiction upon my visit to Star Trek: The Original Series Set Tour in Ticonderoga, New York, a year ago.)

A Gen-Xer, I grew up in the Cold War 1970s and 1980s, devouring reruns of the 1966-69 Original Series. 

Walter Koenig in 1967, 2013
Left: promotional image via Pixabay CC0 1.0
Right: Gage Skidmore via Wikimedia Commons CC BY-SA 3.0
 
Conventional wisdom back then held that Chekov was added to the cast in season 2 to correct the omission of a Russian on the multi-ethnic bridge crew. According to The Making of Star Trek (1968), a book ostensibly co-authored by Star Trek creator Gene Roddenberry, the Russian daily Pravda had called out Star Trek utopianism as hypocritical American imperialism for want of a Russian character. Roddenberry accepted the critique and moved to make amends with the addition of ship's navigator Chekov. 

William Shatner told a different story, however, in his co-authored Star Trek Memories (1993). Shatner wrote that the Pravda story was a publicity stunt that Roddenberry made up. 

No Pravda story as Roddenberry described has ever been found. Yet the truth might lie somewhere in between. Snopes co-founder David Mikkelson took a deep dive on the question in 1999. He concluded that someone had told Roddenberry about a Pravda story, and Roddenberry probably was genuine in saying he acted on it. And why not? Chekov was good for both franchise publicity and Roddenberry's transcultural vision.

Roddenberry's and Shatner's narratives agreed on a different aspect of the character. Regardless of ethnicity, Roddenberry and Star Trek's Paramount producers wanted a younger character on the bridge to draw in youthful viewers. According to Mikkelson, Roddenberry, insightfully keyed into the popular culture, conceived of a character evocative of The Beatles or The Monkees, specifically teen idol Davy Jones. When Koenig first appeared as Chekov, he even wore a mop-top wig until he could grow out Davy-esque locks.

Anton Yelchin, 2011
Georges Biard via
Wikimedia Commons

CC BY-SA 3.0
A good related story about Chekov's debut concerns his Eastern European accent. Koenig said he drew on his heritage to come up with the speech pattern. Born to Russian-Jewish parents, he was, however, a Chicago native. The accent was wholly affected, and critics often have described it as "campy," more caricature than authentic rendering. Long before both perestroika and the internet, most American viewers knew no better. 

Yet cast as Chekov in the 2009 Star Trek reboot film, Anton Yelchin was capable of the real thing. Also of Russian-Jewish origin, Yelchin was born in St. Petersburg and moved to the United States as a baby with his parents. He grew up speaking Russian at home.

Though Yelchin could have put on an authentic accent, he chose to embrace some Cold War camp as a nod to the original Koenig portrayal. 

A tip off to Yelchin's homage is the substitution of a w sound for the letter v, as in "nuclear wessels": a line that Koenig self-deprecatingly repeated to comedic effect as Chekov in Star Trek IV. Yelchin, who died in a tragic accident in 2016, at age 27, knew that a true Eastern European-accented English rather tends to substitute a v sound for the letter w, not the other way around.

Anyway, for me as a kid, the Chekov strategy fired on all warp cylinders; I bought what Roddenberry was selling. I did identify with Chekov's youth. I became a supporter of both the United Federation of Planets and, to end the Cold War, the United Nations. And I became a Trekker for life. 

Patrick Stewart, 2013
Gage Skidmore via Flickr CC BY-SA 2.0
Patrick Stewart hit the small screen as Captain Picard in 1987. I was 16. I remember having friends over to watch the Encounter at Farpoint premiere. 

Stewart's Received Pronunciation of the Shakespearean school was hardly Davy Jones's Mancunian. But it was just the thing for the countless stirring lines he delivered on themes of humanity, liberty, and leadership.

Stewart the actor spoke often of being inspired by a grade-school English teacher; I am indebted to a few of mine. I'm not sure I have "the right stuff" of a Captain Picard. But already by the end of the 1990s, I had the hair.

I am grateful to Walter Koenig and Patrick Stewart for the characters they gave us. May their souls travel at warp speed in eternal exploration of the heavens.

Monday, November 2, 2026

Professional coach explains mobbing, other social dysfunctions that cause workplace trauma

Coach Heffernan analogizes workplace mobbing
to William Golding's Lord of the Flies (1954).

Cry of the Hunters (2011) by Eljiasan,
via DeviantArt, CC BY-NC-ND 3.0
Personal and executive coach Lynda Heffernan, architect of "A Kaizen Mind," has posted a brilliant video explainer of workplace mobbing.

I admit, I can be a person who rolls the eyes upon hearing words such as "cognitive behavioral hypnotherapy," or just "coach" when not attached to a sport team. But after spending some time with Heffernan's substantive content and video channel, I've concluded that this coach is worth listening to. She's the real deal, clinically trained in cognitive neuroscience.

"Kaizen" refers to a Japanese philosophy of continuous, incremental betterment (Forbes, Medium). Lausanne, Switzerland-based Heffernan has adapted the concept to a strategic mindset for self-improvement. In plain English, she does leadership and development training for organizations and executives.

The video on workplace mobbing (Oct. 19, 2026, embedded below) is the fourth in a series about related, trauma-inducing social dynamics, including workplace bullying, gaslighting, and ostracism. Here is the description of the video on mobbing:

In this video, I introduce you to the Island, and to workplace mobbing. If you read Lord of the Flies at school, you'll remember how a group of perfectly ordinary boys, stranded together, gradually turned on one of their own. Nobody set out to be cruel. But once the group had chosen its target, each small act made the next one easier. Mobbing is closely related to bullying, but with one important difference. It isn't one person. It's a whole island. 

Gratifyingly, Heffernan is well versed in the sociological origins and research of workplace mobbing, so she recognizes its discrete nature, especially thanks to the work of my friend and colleague, Dr. Kenneth Westhues. Somewhat jealously defining that distinctiveness is a key part of the mission of the World Association for Research on Workplace Mobbing (WARWM), which I have served as a co-founder and officer along with Dr. Qingli Meng and Dr. Westhues, and of WARWM's annual Conference on Workplace Mobbing at Niagara University (at The Savory Tort), ably led by Dr. Meng.

Incidentally, the fifth entry in the video series also might be of especial interest to the legal community, as Heffernan spoke on the bystander effect. She referenced the classic film 12 Angry Men (1957), and the 1964 Kitty Genovese case, eye-openingly explored in the James Solomon documentary, The Witness (2015) (YouTube). Bystander effect and "Kitty Genovese syndrome" are discussed in connection with tort law in my Tortz, volume 2 (pp. 400-02, 2026 ed.) (SSRN, Lulu).

Understanding workplace mobbing, especially as distinct from its close relative, bullying, literally can save lives. As Heffernan observed in the video, "[B]eing targeted by a group is not proof that the group is right. Very often it's proof that you were willing to see something that they weren't."